Kelli BerglundSally Sullivan
Jake BuseyCharlie Sullivan
Olivia LarsenZoe
Royce JohnsonSheriff D.
Maria OlsenThe Witch
Nikki BlonskyMrs. E
Jason James RichterDeputy T
Shifra ZuckermanDonna • Sidekick
Grace NarducciKaren • Sidekick
Joseph D'OnofrioDeputy Simmons
Zebedee RowBilly Sullivan